May 09, 2014
The recent controversy over rancher Cliven Bundy of Bunkerville led to a lot of references to an earlier fight between ranchers and the federal government … the Sagebrush Rebellion. We thought it might be useful to look back and remind you of what that was all about.
Yes, westerners long had objected to the amount of land the federal government controlled. But the issue also involved HOW the feds controlled it and what they did with it. Ranchers had objected to the Taylor Grazing Act of 1934, which changed how they could use federal land. They didn’t like the creation of the Bureau of Land Management in 1946 to administer those lands. And they weren’t happy about the large areas set aside as wilderness in the 1960s and early 1970s, or when the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 exerted and expanded federal control.
After that, the BLM suggested setting aside millions of acres of federal land in Nevada as wilderness. In 1979, the Nevada legislature responded. Dean Rhoads was a longtime legislator who also was an Elko County rancher. Rhoads introduced a bill demanding that about fifty million acres of federal land be given to the states to control. Four other states passed similar laws.
You might not be surprised to know that reactions were mixed, even within the states in question. Party lines weren’t at issue. The Sagebrush Rebels, as they were known, got support from Republican U.S. senator Paul Laxalt and Democratic congressman Jim Santini. Critics included not just environmental groups, but a well respected Republican, Cliff Young, a former congressman then serving in the state senate.
The Sagebrush Rebellion seemed to gather steam in the 1980 presidential election. During the campaign, Ronald Reagan said, “Count me in as a rebel.” The rebels were optimistic when Reagan won the presidency and appointed as his secretary of the interior James Watt, who made clear that he didn’t have sympathy for the environmental movement that had led to the wilderness designations.
But the Sagebrush Rebels didn’t get quite what they wanted. Watt did scale back wilderness designations. But the Reagan administration did not want to give public lands to the states. If anything, they wanted to sell those lands, much as the federal government had done for generations. That was definitely not what the Sagebrush Rebels wanted.
Nonetheless, the Sagebrush Rebellion died down. Historically, some movements have lost at least part of their momentum when they achieve a degree of success, and the Rebels did have some success. Nor were they likely to elect someone more sympathetic than Reagan.
Since then, rural westerners have continued to criticize the federal government, at times with support from conservatives without such close ties to the land. There also have been challenges to federal authority over public lands. In 1994, Nye County Commissioner Dick Carver used his plow to open a road the federal government had closed. The Jarbidge Shovel Brigade did something similar in Elko County in 2000. Whether those actions were part of the Sagebrush Rebellion could be debated; they certainly reflected unhappiness with the federal government, as did the supporters who gathered around Cliven Bundy. It’s an old debate, and it’s going to continue.
See discussion rules
|Sep 5, 2014 | The Beatles|
It's been a half century since the Beatles had a 'hard day's night,' right here in Las Vegas. The real thing - John, Paul, George and Ringo - arrived on August 20, 1964. Their performance lasted for about 30-minutes as part of a show that included the Righteous Brothers and Jackie DeShannon.
|Aug 22, 2014 | Civil Rights Act|
When the Civil Rights Act was passed a half century ago, not everyone within Nevada's political circles was onboard with it. The decision was not a simple one for some Nevada Senators.
|Aug 1, 2014 | Bob Bailey|
How much can one person accomplish? If you're like Bob Bailey, quite a bit. From show business to civil rights on the Strip, Here's Senator Richard Bryan with a look back at the life of Bob Bailey.
|Jul 11, 2014 | Remembering Bob Faiss|
Mixing law with the gaming industry seemed a natural fit for one Las Vegas attorney, who passed away recently. Here's a look back at the influence of attorney Bob Faiss on the gaming industry.
|May 16, 2014 | Viva Las Vegas|
"Viva Las Vegas" turns 50 in a few days. We'll hear how Las Vegas itself starred in the iconic movie, along side Elvis. Moviegoers got a taste of Southern Nevada and a song to go with it!
|May 9, 2014 | Sagebrush Rebels|
A rancher challenging federal authority over land rights in Nevada has been in the news recently, but it's not the first time the subject has been a hot topic. Remembering the "Sagebrush Rebellion" on Nevada Yesterdays.
|Apr 18, 2014 | Metro Battles Corruption and the Mob|
Efforts to drive organized crime out of Las Vegas, left one former Metro officer, Kent Clifford, with some controversies of his own.
|Mar 21, 2014 | Natalie Rittenhouse|
Family connections run deep for some pioneer families of Southern Nevada. Perhaps they aren't too well known these days. They should be. They are among the important pioneer families of southern Nevada.
|Mar 7, 2014 | Test Ban|
Strange as it may seem now, there was a time when detonating a nuclear bomb was healthy for Nevada's image.
|Feb 21, 2014 | Green Felt Jungle|
The pen is mightier than the roulette table? Some books over the years have tested that notion. Fifty years ago, a book about Las Vegas became a best-seller. But not everyone was happy with what the book had to say about the influence of organized crime on Las Vegas casinos.
|Jan 16, 2014 | Martin Luther King, Jr.|
Fifty years have gone by since Martin Luther King, Jr. made his way to Las Vegas, in a visit that had an impact. Local leaders had won the right to patronize once segregated casinos, but they hoped King would reinvigorate the local movement.
|Jan 3, 2014 | Treaty of Ruby Valley|
A treaty that was signed in the territory of Nevada 150 years ago is still raising questions. The Western Shoshone tribe has been offered tens of millions of dollars by the US government, but they say no thanks. In 1974, sisters Mary and Carrie Dann of Beowawe, became symbols of the tribes resistance.
|Dec 5, 2013 | Lon Simmons|
We take a look at how a legendary sports-broadcaster forged a path from Las Vegas to Candlestick Park. Switching from pitcher to broadcaster turned out to be a home run decision for Lon Simmons. Here's Senator Richard Bryan with Nevada Yesterdays.
|Nov 20, 2013 | JFK and Las Vegas Connections|
Elements of John F. Kennedy's ties to Las Vegas have been mixed in with the
puzzle-pieces surrounding his death. Las Vegas and Nevada were part of the orbit of the Kennedys, their allies, and their enemies. Senator Richard Bryan connects the dots on Nevada Yesterdays.
|Sep 20, 2013 | Constitution|
How about the great State of Washoe or Esmeralda? When residents of this territory considered statehood 150 years ago, it took more than one attempt to get them to agree on a name and on how much to tax the lucrative gold and silver mines.
|Sep 1, 2013 | Sawyer v. Sinatra|
It was around Labor Day 50 years ago, that Nevada's little black book caused some friction for Frank Sinatra. A mobster who was in the black book was seen in the Cal-Neva Lodge in Lake Tahoe and Sinatra was part owner...
|Aug 2, 2013 | Dorothy Gallagher|
Dorothy Gallagher never gave up on access to higher education for people living in rural areas.
|Jul 12, 2013 | A Big Fight|
Some boxing matches in Las Vegas have carried more weight than just a heavyweight title.
|Jun 14, 2013 | Tarkanian, Part II|
UNLV's Runnin' Rebels were coached by a man who was thought to be something of a rebel himself.
|Jun 7, 2013 | Tarkanian, Part I|
To make it into the Basketball hall of fame, Jerry Tarkanian must have done something right.