Nevada Public Radio Listen Live

"RadioLab"
Facebook Twitter Follow Nevada Public Radio

Support Nevada Public Radio
January 27, 2005
Podcasts

ARCHIVE: Employee Rights

Listen

Last week a Reno bartender filed for a 9th Circuit Court hearing, claiming that Harrahs' rules requiring her to wear make-up caused her to be fired from a 20-year career with the company. KNPR's Ky Plaskon reports

PLASKON: The Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits employers from denying jobs based on race, religion, national origin, or sex. Ever since it's been used in court to allow men to work as nurses, to stop airlines from requiring stewardesses to be skinny, and when the investment firm Price Waterhouse denied a promotion to a banker because her appearance wasn't effeminate enough, in 1982 the Supreme Court ruled that was a violation the Act. But for the past 5 years it has failed in the defense of a former Harrahs bartender. Jenny Pizer is her attorney.

PIZER: People are expressing alarm as a roll back to a generation ago as a way for employers to impose unclear rules on women and just on women with a message that they are supposed to behave like women and act like women as in stay in your place, stay in your place behave and look this way or you will lose your job.

PLASKON: Pizer, an attorney with Lambda Legal Defense, a nation-wide gay civil rights organization, is defending former Harrahs Bartender Darlene Jesperson. After 20 years working for Harrahs, Jesperson was fired in August 2000 when the company instituted what it called a "Personal Best" policy. Harrahs spokesman Gary Thompson knows the policy.

THOMPSON: Some of the requirements for hair styles and make up were eased.

PLASKON:The requirements may have been less strict, but they were more strictly enforced. For the first time Harrahs required Jesperson to wear make-up. Thompson explains the strong enforcement was necessary because employees and customers wanted it at recently acquired properties.

THOMPSON: There were not uniform standards across properties and our customers where were accustomed to certain standards of cleanliness and were complaining about what they were witnessing there."

PLASKON: But Jesperson's bar wasn't one of those newly acquired properties.

THOMPSON: In fact we have owned that property for over 40 years.

PLASKON: The "personal best" policy, which is still in place at Harrahs, says that women must wear blush, foundation and lipstick "at all times", and that men shouldn't wear make up at all. Harrahs came up with the policy using an airline consultant and according to Thompson, Harrahs implemented the policy because case law supports it.

THOMPSON: If you are a news anchor on TV even the men wear make up and so there are certain jobs where women are required to wear make up.

PLASKON: But that's the problem for Jesperson. At Harrahs only women are required to wear make-up, not men. Thompson says Harrahs offered Jesperson her job back and even told her she didn't have to wear make-up.

THOMPSON: We did offer an exception. And to a lot of people who are passionate about it they loose that passion. When you go to work you are expected to have certain clothing standards.

PLASKON: Pizer says it didn't matter if she could get her job back, Jesperson who is now working three retail jobs decided to take a stand against Harrahs' new policy.

PIZER: And for many years they had been pushing women to wear make up and she knew full well that there were plenty of women who hated theat policy, there weren't any that were willing to stand up and loose their jobs. And she was really worried that if she came back accepted reinstatement with exemption from the policy she would be isolated. They had to work together as a team. It is very difficult for an employee if they are getting preferred treatment if the other workers see that they are getting special treatment so it didn't seem that that was going to be workable.

PLASKON: Ever since Jesperson is at the center of what Pizer considers an emerging area of Civil Rights Act law. In the past the Act was used to successfully argue that employer can require stereotypical uniforms as long as they are applied equally.

SOUND: Hard Rock Hotel

PLASKON: Here at the Hard Rock Hotel, cocktail waitresses wear fishnets, tight shorts and tops. Under the common application of the civil rights act, Pizer says if men were given cocktail server jobs they would be required to wear similar outfits as women.

PIZER: If you applied that rule you might say that the guys need to go bare chested and wear skimpy shorts or look like Chippendales and costume if the women are going to wear fishnets and tight blouses, and under the old rule that wouldn't be sex discrimination because each group of people are being burdened they are all unhappy, they are all being burdened in an unequal way.

PLASKON: In December a panel of the Ninth Circuit ruled 2-to-1 that Jesperson didn't prove the make-up requirement burdened women more than men. With the hope of getting the case re-heard by the full Ninth Circuit, Pizer is now arguing that Harrahs' rules violate the Civil Rights Act because they force conformity to stereotypes even if those stereotypes are applied equally.

PIZER: So in fact both groups are being discriminated against instead of neither.

PLASKON: She says that if the court doesn't rehear the case it will invite employers to implement extreme rules to entice and titillate customers. Harrahs says it should be able to enforce the same rules as strip clubs and heavy metal bars. The full Ninth Circuit is expected to announce if it will hear the case within the next two months and if denied, Lambda Legal Defense has said it may appeal to the Supreme Court.

Ky Plaskon, News 88-9, KNPR

See discussion rules.

Archives

Apr 4, 2009 | Drug Donation Program
Nevada lawmakers are debating the creation of a program that would help cancer patients get expensive prescription drugs for less.

Mar 13, 2009 | Budget Wrangling
As state lawmakers wrestle with Nevada's multi-billion-dollar budget deficit, there are several plans afoot aimed at softening the next economic bust.

Mar 2, 2009 | Autism
The cost of treating children with autism can be $24,000 to $40,000 per child per year according to the Autism Coalition of Nevada. A bill before the Nevada Legislature aims to help families pay for the care.

Feb 16, 2007 | Chinese New Year
This weekend marks a celebration of Chinese New Year. KNPR's Rick Andrews reports on how the holiday is being celebrated by the valley's growing Asian community.

Dec 7, 2006 | Food and Beverage
The economy of scale for food and beverage operations in Las Vegas means any edge in efficiency is real money. Rick Andrews reports on a software product scoring with food and beverage managers looking at the bottom line...and what you're likely to order.

Nov 15, 2006 | Global Gaming Expo
The Global Gaming Expo trade show and conference got underway Tuesday in Las Vegas. Vendors showcase their latest wares including new slot machines.

Nov 1, 2006 | Stardust Memories
When it opened in 1958 the Stardust was the world's largest hotel. Now, after more than 48 years, it's closed.

Sep 27, 2006 | Nevada Northern Railway
The 'Nevada Northern' is celebrating its centenial anniversary. News 88.9's Rick Andrews went on a tour of the museum with executive director Mark Bassett.

Jun 30, 2006 | Standing Up for Ringo
Congresswoman Shelley Berkley tells the story of how she saw the Beatles in Las Vegas in August 1964.

Jun 29, 2006 | Sports Supplements
From fortified cereals to energy drinks to serious sports nutrition, people are willing to spend lots money to supplement their diets. Rick Andrews reports on the business of sports supplements.

May 25, 2006 | Love
Wednesday Cirque du Soleil provided a glimpse of their much anticipated show based on the music of the Beatles. Flo Rogers reports on Love.

May 24, 2006 | Telecommunications
A Senate telecommunications bill currently being considered includes provisions on most everything, but some worry that controversial measures will derail the entire package.

May 16, 2006 | Nanotech
Universities across the country are spending millions to expand nano technology research...manipulating molecules 10,000 times smaller than a human hair. Rick Andrews reports on nano research at UNLV.

Apr 24, 2006 | Earthscope
Hualapai Mountain Park, near Kingman, has been chosen by the National Science Foundation to be home to a seismic monitoring station. Gillian Ferris Kohl reports.

Apr 18, 2006 | Anatomical Donation for Science
In the second of two reports exploring innovative medical facilities in the Valley, Rick Andrews visits the Medical Education and Research Institute of Nevada in Henderson.

Apr 12, 2006 | Immigration Reform Stalled
Immigration legislation in the U.S. Senate is at a standstill. Many in the Republican Party blame Nevada Democrat, Senator Harry Reid for the impasse. Jill Morrison reports from Capitol Hill.

Apr 1, 2006 | New Plans for Nellis
The first of April brings news that a large piece of military land in Las Vegas may be redeveloped.

Mar 28, 2006 | Test Site Worker Compensation
Senator Harry Reid is trying to get compensation for Test Site workers who were exposed to dangerous levels of radiation, but never compensated.

Feb 27, 2006 | StoryCorps - Alice Keys
Alice Keys has been active in the African American community for decades and known through her association with the Moulin Rouge Casino. Here's her recollection of meeting one of the great African Americans of the last century.

Feb 21, 2006 | StoryCorps - Alan Morel and Mike Genoshe
When close friends interview each other, the stories are often more intimate and revealing than talking to a reporter. A case in point is Alan Morel and Mike Genoshe talking about their hopes for their adopted son.

© 2013 NEVADA PUBLIC RADIO   
Web hosting facilities provided by Switch.